| Gilmore R. Guirao | One of my favorite channels on YouTube. It's nice to hear some classic horror stories instead of just creepypast  | 
| Cordelia Zayitilow | Grade A stuff! I'm unquestionably in your debt!  | 
| Baconlover0 | You guys are amazing! Whenever I'm bored I will listen to your awesome stories for hours. Again, y'all are amazing! Keep up the great work!  | 
| Brettd07 | I love these stories. I was glad to finally find a podcast that was actually scary. The stories and story tellers are all amazing. The podcasts come out frequently so there is always a new story. This is one of the best podcasts out there.  | 
| TheGaurdianSeesYou | Wow, I'm blown away by how cool this is.  | 
| Sinai Martinez | I only wish I had found Chilling Tales for Dark Nights sooner.  | 
| MultiWorldwideGamers | Words cannot comprehend how amazing your channel and videos are. I've been up since 2 AM on some mornings, just watching/listening to your amazing, well-narrated creepy pastas and stories. I love the thrill of being scared, and you provide that scare perfectly. Keep up the amazing job!  | 
| OfficialRabbits | I just wanted to say your channel is the most scary I've ever seen. I really enjoy listening to your stories. Keep up the incredibly good work.  | 
| Coy Truman | I love your videos. My wife showed one to me and now I'm hooked. It's clear yours is the go-to channel for horror stories, keep it up!  | 
| Anne Mitra | I loved The Simply Scary Podcast from the start, discovered it about 5 months ago from a link in the Noctrium library. Best of luck for future series!  | 
| iloveu serenity wolf | I love you, Chilling Tales for Dark Nights! You are part of my family. I consider everyone I'm subscribed to my family. You are the monster under my bed that comforts me yet makes me hide in terror.  | 
| Arletrose Bunny | You guys are amazing in what you do - the sounds and effects are so good, it really makes it more enjoyable to watch! Great job!  | 
| Hazel Silva | You guys rock! I just discovered your website via YouTube. It's awesome. The voice actors are pretty good and the sound effects? Man, oh, man.. really creepstatic! We will be featuring you on our blog soon! It's not much, but I hope it could help. Thank you for creating awesome audio stories.  | 
| BlammingWaffles77 | I just happened to accidentally find this channel, but damn is it a "happy" accident. Your stories don't send chills down my spine or a rush of endorphins to the brain like Mr. Creepypasta's stories, but your voice and the depth and visual-detailing prowess from your words is just pure otherworldly, far better than any channel I've seen. Like someone already stated, you're more so a psychological style of horror, one that gets me thinking. Love this channel, so you sir have +1 subscriber!  | 
| Carl Rath | Chilling Tales for Dark Nights is an amazing work of art! Bone-chilling stories are an amazing nod to the dark fears that lie in our souls, while giving us a thrill. God bless you all for persevering and uploading such epics!  | 
| Rhaegar Targaryen | Glad I subscribed to this channel - best decision I ever made, no regrets at all. Well done, guys!  | 
| Shakeem Siler | Great jobs, guys! Keep up the great work! Can't wait for the next upload!  | 
| Ronnie James | I would just like to say the narration and the voice acting is superb by you guys. I love most of your stories! You guys should have way more subscribers! Kudos to the writers as well.  | 
| boretyy | I recommended your channel to some of my friends and they subscribed, too. We are having a lot of fun listening to your creepy stories. You are really good and you deserve more subscribers.  | 
| Jamie Flynn | You guys are amazing! I love, love, love your stories! Keep it up!  | 
| pianonextdoor | Awesome! What a great channel!  | 
| Bigtimerush Fan | Chilling Tales for Dark Nights rocks! I subscribed!  | 
| Crimson Wizard | You guys will always be one of my top favorite channels!  | 
| VideoGameDude20 | Oh my! I'm so happy I've found this channel!  | 
| Matthew Adams | To Chilling Tales for Dark Nights and to Craig, who is in the charge of the show, good job with the stories! Keep up the good work!  | 
| Joe Didely | One of my favorite things about Chilling Tales for Dark Nights is that they interact with their fans, not a lot of people do that.  | 
| Tiffany Ro |  Chilling Tales never ceases to make my skin crawl in the most wonderful way.  | 
| Cody Wharden | I'm going to get my friends to try and help to get you guys more views and get your name out there. You guys ought to be all but synonymous with Mr. Creepypasta.  | 
| M. Hale | You guys are absolutely awesome! Glad I subscribed! I've grown tired of listening to Mrcreepypasta, CMP, CPJ using the same expressions on their videos. You guys truly know how to add FEAR to your narrations!  | 
| Burnt Blonde | 199,000 subscribers? Can’t wait till you hit 500,000....this channel just hasn’t been discovered yet!  | 
| Edward Kelber | I've been here since Chilling Tales for Dark Nights had 100 subscribers. I'll be here when they get 1 million!  | 
| Sarah R. Openshaw | I'm a big fan of what you and your team do. I wanted to say thank you for all the work you and everyone put in to the stories and production. 
 | 
| Tom Barter | I am officially hooked on Chilling Tales for Dark Nights!  | 
| Gray Wolfe | I love the stories! They put visions in your head to help you visualize what's going on. Your intro is awesome, too!  | 
| Casey Plotnick | You have an awesome channel! I've subscribed!  | 
| Rachel Jordan | I just wanted to thank you for your readings! Seems quite a few people do, but you have the best voices for reading horror stories, in my opinion! Your stories keep my ears constantly attentive and needing to hear the next words. My boyfriend and I love to cuddle into bed at night and put on a few of your stories each night and always get creeped out! I am looking forward to your future videos!  | 
| Allen Featherstone | Great podcast! Keep up the awesome work!  | 
| T.E. Grau (Author) | I love audio books, and love radio dramas from way back. The cinema of the mind is such a powerful place. Your website/channel looks pretty damn cool. Thanks for your interest in my work!  | 
| Shakeem Siler | Hope you guys get a million subscribers eventually!  | 
| Connor McNamara | I love getting into work and seeing a new video posted. I know that at least I'll have an hour and twenty minutes of happiness today.  | 
| PinkPrincessLolita | Amazingly scary! I subscribed! Well done!  | 
| CjRaptor Z | What I like about you guys is that you don't rely on gimmicky scary pictures to make your videos creepy - you use your talented narration skills. Well done.  | 
| Jake Kalender | This is easily my favorite horror channel on YouTube! Thanks for the nightmares, guys!  | 
| Chelsea Giguere | Just wanted to say I'm a HUGE fan of what you do. I listen almost every single day and simply can't get enough. The longer ones are a perfect substitute to music when wanting something to listen to when cleaning the house.  | 
| Frances Haypenny | You gentlemen are reviving a lost art, a great art form that stirs the imagination like no other. New generations can experience what it was like to huddle close to the radio and be mesmerized because of all your hard work and loving dedication to the genre. Thank you all so much and I hope this takes off like gangbusters.  | 
| Keoke Tautua Alofaituli | If only I could give Chilling Tales for Dark Nights a higher rating, I would! They are simply the best in horror storytelling available! Their actors bring the words to life!  | 
| Kris Mallory (Author) | Chilling Tales for Dark Nights always delivers.  | 
| Wolf Kalevala | I can't stop listening to these scary stories. You guys are amazing. Good job!  | 
| MrLUIS650 | I love how you guys read these stories and how you use sound effects!  | 
| bbblly | People should give you more credit! Your YouTube channel is awesome! I love to listen to these tales while on the train!  |